Borders
are not something accursed. Borders are what give
a person his or her identity as an Indian or Pakistani
or Bangladeshi. Different cultural identities exist
in our world only because of these borders. But after
seeing Pakistani director Mehreen Jabber’s debut
film Ramchand Pakistani, the viewer will curse such
borders.
The
film deals with a Hindu Pakistani dalit family separated
at the time of the 2002 Parliament attack that shattered
hopes for peace between India and Pakistan. Eight-year-old
Ramchand (Syed Fazal Hussain) and his father, Shankar
(Rashid Farooqui), inadvertently cross the border
into India, where they are arrested and detained as
spies. Ramchand's mother, Champa (Nandita Das), has
no idea of their whereabouts and is traumatized by
their disappearance. Ramachand Pakistani depicts the
sufferings of innocent people held in both Indian
and Pakistani jails. This film makes you think and
reflect on such tragedy. Without being politically
preachy, the director makes the film accessible to
sensitive minds.
A
Pakistani production, the film is a collaboration
between Indian and Pakistani artists. Pakistani cinematographer
Sofian Khan used outstanding wide shots and tight
shots to establish the cultural environment and the
characters' emotions simultaneously. Indian music
director Debajyoti Mishra contributes a score that
does justice to the theme. The actors fit their roles
ideally.
We
all know that secularism, sanity, and safety cannot
become real if we remain "spectators," but
how many films remind us of this — and so poignantly?
Amathul
Wardha
© FIPRESCI 2008